Skip to main content

Bestsellers

Customer Favorites, Zero Guesswork

These are the most-loved items at Keys—picked by hundreds of shoppers. If you’re new here or shopping a quick gift, start below and you’ll be happy with what you grab.

What makes these bestsellers so good?
  • Great value for everyday practice
  • Consistent quality (we reject duds)
  • Easy wins for gifts and starter kits
Looking for something more? Pick your path:

Local to us? Order online and choose Pickup in Lansing at checkout. Want help choosing? Send us a message on Facebook or send us an email.

FAQ: Shipping, Returns & Support

Shipping: Orders of in-stock items are turned around within 72 hours. Pre-orders take a minimum of 2 weeks to ship; if your pre-order is out-of-stock with our supplier, we will let you know. We use recycled shipping materials when possible.

Returns: Easy returns on unopened/unused items within 30 days. Contact us if anything arrives off—we’ll make it right.

Questions? Send us a message or email; we usually reply quickly during shop hours.


Tip: New to the craft? Start with a cleansing tool (like incense or Palo Santo), a focus stone (selenite or rainbow moonstone), and a divination tool (pendulum or runes). That combo covers a surprising amount of practice.

Refine by
 

Filters

Filters
Restocked
Obsidian Scrying Mirror with Stand
Obsidian Scrying Mirror with Stand
Obsidian Scrying Mirror with Stand
6″ Obsidian Scrying Mirror with Stand – Divination Tool | Keys To Manifestation
$18.95
Keys To Manifestation digital gift certificate graphic with logo, red ribbon, and glittering black background.
Keys To Manifestation Gift Card
Keys To Manifestation Gift Card
Digital shop credit for witchy goodies
$1.00 or more
Palo Santo Sticks
Palo Santo Sticks
Palo Santo Sticks
Palo Santo Sticks (Bursera graveolens) – Natural Smoke Cleansing | Keys To Manifestation
$1.95
Selenite
Selenite
Selenite
Selenite (Satin Spar) — Sticks & Points | Keys To Manifestation
$6.75
Hamsa Protection Bracelet
Hamsa Protection Bracelet
Hamsa Protection Bracelet
Hamsa Protection Bracelet – Glass Beads on Stretch Cord | Keys To Manifestation
$9.95
White Sage 4" Bundles
White Sage 4" Bundles
White Sage 4" Bundles
White Sage Bundle (4″) – California White Sage for Smoke Cleansing | Keys To Manifestation
$4.49
Rainbow Moonstone
Rainbow Moonstone
Rainbow Moonstone
Rainbow Moonstone — Tumbled & Palm Stones (Blue Flash) | Keys To Manifestation
$9.95
Amethyst Rune Set
Amethyst Rune Set
Amethyst Rune Set
Amethyst Rune Set — Elder Futhark with Pouch & Cheat Sheet | Keys To Manifestation
$38.95
Pre-order
Sorcerer's Staff
Sorcerer's Staff
Sorcerer's Staff
Sorcerer’s Staff – 6-Foot Faux-Wood with Lavender Gazing Ball | Keys To Manifestation
$61.95
Satya Nag Champa Sticks
Satya Nag Champa Sticks
Satya Nag Champa Sticks
Satya Nag Champa Incense Sticks (15g Box) – Hand-Rolled Masala | Keys To Manifestation
$3.25
Lavender flowers
Lavender flowers
Lavender flowers
Lavender Flowers (Lavandula angustifolia) – Dried Blossoms for Ritual & Craft | Keys To Manifestation
$8.25